The Birth of the Orator. A Situational Approach to “The Moment’s Glory”
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.13135/2384-8987/2092Keywords:
sensorium, rhetorical situation, risk, autobiography, Jacotot.Abstract
Following recent research devoted to “rhetoric’s sensorium” and “rhetorical situation”, the essay aims at relating the birth of the orator to his “moment of glory”. The analysis departs from the similarities of Mihail Kogălniceanu’s and B.P. Hasdeu’s discontinuous careers, both of them eminent Romanian personalities of the 19th century who gave up literature on account its inherent uncertainty, afterward pursuing success as political orators. Nonetheless, even if both of them discover that sensuality can be converted into brilliant oratory, it is the aspiring orators’ education (both education of senses and institutional education) that makes the difference between the former’s glory and the latter’s failure. A series of examples extracted from early literature and grouped according to the frequency of favored rhetorical effects prove that each one understands “glory” in a different manner, which makes the former a typical persuader (a mediator of experience) and the latter a manipulator (a seeker of the Absolute). Each orator’s manner (persuader vs. manipulator) becomes apparent in the way autobiography is functionalized within political speeches: while Kogălniceanu formalizes autobiography so that it becomes a trope enabling the orator to reinvent himself in any new rhetorical situation may occur, Hasdeu attaches autobiography to a sense of exceptionalism. Hence, the relationship between the birth of the orator and his moment of glory is discernible not only in his awakening of senses but also in the orator’s (aptitude for) rebirth in new situations.References
A. Sources
*** (1936), Mihail Kogălniceanu. Ciclu de conferințe ținute la Radio București în februarie 1935, Bucharest, Cultural Foundation “Mihail Kogălniceanu”.
Hadeu, B.P. (1973), Duduca Mamuca. Din memoriile unui studinte, edited by Ion Șeuleanu, Cluj Napoca, Dacia Publishers.
Hasdeu, B.P. (2006), Opere IV. Publicistica politica, edited by Stancu Ilin and I. Oprisan, Bucharest, FNSA-Univers Enciclopedic Publishers.
Hasdeu, B.P. (2006), Opere. I. Poezii. Proza, edited by Stancu Ilin and I. Oprisan, Bucharest, FNSA-Univers Enciclopedic Publishers.
Kogălniceanu, M. (1964), Tainele inimei. Scrieri alese, Bucharest, EPL.
Kogălniceanu, M. (1974), Opere I. Beletristica, studii literare, culturale și sociale, edited by Dan Simonescu, Bucharest, RSR Academy Publishers.
Kogalniceanu, M. (1987), Opere III. Oratory I. 1856-1864, edited by Dan Simonescu, notes and comentaries by Vladimir Diculescu, introduction by Dan Berindei, Bucharest, RSR Academy Publishers.
Patraș, R. (2016), Oratorie politică românească, vol. 1, Iași, “Alexandru Ioan Cuza” University Press.
Patraș, R. (2016), Oratorie politică românească, vol. 2, Iași, “Alexandru Ioan Cuza” University Press.
B. Secondary Literature
Anghelescu, M. (2015), Lâna de aur. Călătorii și călătoriile în literatura română, Bucharest, Cartea românească Publishers.
Anghelescu, M. (2016), Mistifictiuni. Falsuri, farse, aprocrife, pastișe, parodii, pseudonime și alte mistificații în literatură, 2nd edition revised and completed, Bucharest, Spandugino Publishers.
Aristotle (2004), Rhetoric, translated into Romanian by Maria-Cristina Andrieș, notes and comments by Ștefan-Sebastian Maftei, Bucharest, IRI Publishers.
Bitzer, Lloyd (1968), The Rhetorical Situation, “Philosphy and Rhetoric”, 1, pp. 1-14.
Burghele, G.G. (1901), Mihail Kogălniceanu. Conferință..., Bucharest, “Eminescu” Institute of Graphic Arts.
Călinescu, G. (1982), Istoria literaturii române de la origini până în prezent, 2nd edition revised and completed, Bucharest, Minerva Publishers.
Cartojan, N. (1942), Mihail Kogălniceanu. Activitatea literară, în Academia Română. Memoriile secțiunii literare, 3rd series, tome XI, Bucharest, Lupta Națională Publishers.
Cassin, B. (1995), L’effet sophistique, Paris, Gallimard.
Cicero (1967), De oratore, translated into English by E. W. Sutton, London, Heinemann-Harvard UP.
Cicero (1942), De oratore, with an English translation by E.W. Sutton, London, William Heineman.
Coquelin, A (1999), L’art du lieu commun. Du bon usage de la “doxa”, Paris, Editions du Seuil.
Cornea, P. (2008), Originile romantismului românesc, 2nd edition, Bucharest, Cartea Românească Publishers.
Demetriescu, A (1937), Opere, Bucharest, “Regele Carol II” Foundation for Literature and Arts.
Gusti, D. (1984), Ritorică pentru tinerimea studioasă, edited by Mircea Frânculescu, Bucharest, Editura științifică și enciclopedică Publishers.
Hawhee, D. (2015), Rhetoric’s Sensorium, in “Quarterly Journal of Speech”, vol. 101 (1), pp. 2-17.
Iorga, N. (1920), Mihail Kogălniceanu, scriitorul, omul politic și românul, Bucharest, Socec Publishers.
Lăzăreanu, B. (n.d.), Umorul lui Hasdeu, Bucharest, Adevărul Publishers.
Macé, M. (2016), Styles. Critiques de nos forms de vie, Paris, Gallimard.
Macintyre, A. (2007), After Virtue. A study in Moral Theory, 3rd edition, Notre Dame-Indiana, University of Notre Dame Press.
McLuhan, M. (1975), The Gutenberg Galaxy, translated into Romanian by L. & P. Năvodaru, foreword by V.E. Mașek, Bucharest, Editura politică Publishers.
McLuhan, M. (2011), The Gutenberg Galaxy, Toronto, University of Toronto Press, https://books.google.ro.
McLuhan, M. (2011), Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man, translated into Romanian by Ovidiu George Vitan, Bucharest, Curtea Veche Publishers.
Oprisan, I. (2001), B. P. Hasdeu sau setea de Absolut. Tumultul și misterul vieții, Bucharest, Saeculum Publishers.
Perelman, C. & Olbrechts-Tyteca, L. (2012), Tratat de argumentare. Noua retorică, translated into Romanian by Aurelia Stoica, prefaced by Michel Meyer, Iași, “Alexandru Ioan Cuza” University Press.
Poulakos, J.(1983), Toward a Sophistic Definition of Rhetoric, in “Philosophy and Rhetoric”, vol 16 (1), pp. 35-48.
Quintilian (1974), Arta oratorică, vol. 1-3, translated into Romanian, prefaced and annoted by Maria Hețco, Bucharest, Minerva Publishers.
Rancière, J. (1991), The Ignorant Schoolmaster. Five Lessons in Intellectual Emancipation, translated with and introduction by Kristin Ross, Stanford, Stanford UP.
Rancière, J. (1998), La Chair des Mots, Paris, Éditions Galilée.
Roussin, P. (1996), Retorica, in Ducrot, O. & Schaeffer, J.-M. (eds.), Enciclopedia științelor limbajului, translated into Romanian by Anca Măgureanu, Viorel Vișan, Marina Păunescu, Bucharest, Babel Publishers.
Sălăvăstru, C. (2010), Mic tratat de oratorie, Iași, Editura Universității „Alexandru Ioan Cuza”.
Urechia, V.A. (1878), Despre elocința română. Oratoria forense, amvonul, haranga. Oratorii moderni. Panu, Barbu Catargiu, Cogălniceanu, Bratianu &. &. Lectura publică ţinută în 12/24 decembrie 1866, Bucharest, Carol Göbl Publishers.
Warburg, Aby (2016), Essais Florentins, Paris, Hazan.
Zamfir, Mihai (2011), Scurtă istorie. Panorama alternativă a literaturii române, Bucharest, Cartea românească Publishers.
Zub, Alexandru (2012), Mihail Kogălniceanu, istoric, 2nd edition, Iași, “Alexandru Ioan Cuza” University Press.
C. Electronic resources
Aristotle, Rhetoric, translated by W. Rhys Roberts, http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/rhetoric.3.iii.html.
Downloads
Additional Files
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
RiCognizioni is published under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
With the licence CC-BY, authors retain the copyright, allowing anyone to download, reuse, re-print, modify, distribute and/or copy their contribution. The work must be properly attributed to its author.
It is not necessary to ask further permissions both to author or journal board.
