"Who said that?". An emblematic case of a misallocated attribution

Abstract

This article discusses the real authorship of a sentence erroneously attributed to Giovanni Battista Morgagni (1682-1771) but actually by the French physician François Joseph Victor Broussais (1772-1838). This exemplary case shows how a single erroneous attribution risks being reproposed over time, consolidating itself in the scientific literature, so much to replace the original authorship with an erroneous one. It follows the absolute necessity to always and rigorously verify the accuracy of a sentence attributed to a certain author, both in form and in content, as well as in its real authorship.